Tuesday, August 13, 2013

Tubig and the “too vague” law

Early this year, Roan Abasalo and I were tasked to translate the Davao City Watershed Code into Bisaya. I gave half of the chapters to him. Roan as a government broadcast media worker for many years had a penchant for the job. Like my neighbor here in the pages of Mindanao Journal, Sir King Quimpan, Roan is also “bagtik” in the mother tongue. One should take extra pre-caution to give an accurate translation of the proviso to save the trouble of being scolded by framers of the law.

In good faith, such self-proclaimed version was hoped to pass all strict scrutiny, with the evil being avoided. But more often, we can be “lost in translation”, like a toddler lost in the offing. A translation job is seriously funny at times as you are not only stretching thin the law, you could also lose its real meaning when written in another language. Such could pop up many dialog balloons of jokes at the end of each line when you read your work, but not for the experts.

Registering in our radar screen are those who play a Smart Aleck in Congress with Senate Bill 2997, proposed by Senator Angara and House Bill No. 5497, proposed by Reps Romero Federico Quimbo and Karlo Nograles, which seek to privatize all of the country’s water districts. This proposed law that is tripping us up gets in the way of naming Davao’s icon of abstract logic. This is staining the reputation of Davao to have the best potable water in the world. With this judgment of Nograles, he has also to live with all the consequences because not less than our national hero Dr. Jose P. Rizal said, “True shame encounters eyes everywhere”.

How many wells do we have in the first district that Nograles has been so keen on privatizing our water resource? The Davao City Water District (DCWD) must have a point of influence and point of reference, so to speak on this matter. Being a consistent Most Outstanding Water Utility in Asia (which was awarded in Singapore), privatizing is much like reinventing the wheel. He may have invalidly classified our water district with that of Manila’s MWSS. Poor Davao. By and large these lawmakers, including the young Nograles continue to champion this idea on privatization to the strong opposition of their constituents.

It is the death of commonsense and people will feel being suffocated by all these proposed laws. Is our government ridiculously oversold? In that M-Power forum held in Grand Men Seng Hotel recently, one cracked up: Is P-Noy also wants to privatize the police and military? In response to the arbitrary quality, on how many looked at the agenda of the government gearing towards Public-Private-Partnership (PPP), which also sounds like from protector to protection racket. The government is our protector, the surrogate of the rights-bearer from the ruling class. That is only a punch to the moon (suntok sa buwan).

True, DCWD must have known its potential water customers: the residential, commercial, industrial, government, institutional and other users. But the government must draw the line between service and profit. For water is a utility indispensable to our existence. It is even supposed to be free for the households. So when water rates go up, people will dig their own well and let government worry on the sanitation problem. Big corporations stand to benefit the move on privatizing our water districts.


Every generation has the Smart Alecks who think they can figure everything out, once and for all. We happen to be in the generation that fell for it. But as Justice Cardozo once said: “We must spread the gospel; that there is no gospel to spare us the pain of choosing at every step”. Where do taxes of people go if the most basic service that our government can offer, such as the provision of water will slip from its hands? Ergo, Nograles is scaling the mountain in his proposed law.

No comments:

Post a Comment